Saturday, August 4, 2012

Green Energy How are environmentalists and green energy plans NOT like Communists and five-year plans?

Question by ǝƃɐʞǝpuɐd: How are environmentalists and green energy plans NOT like Communists and five-year plans?
I’m trying to argue that this author (who uses this analogy) is using fallacious reasoning. What are some obvious differences?

The author’s writes the following:
“Just as 20th-century socialists savaged capitalism for all the world's ills and offered worthless "five-year plans" as a replacement, so today's environmentalists savage industrial energy and offer us "green energy plans" that they assure us will work–once we give them the power to forbid everything else that has already been proven to work.”

Any ideas on disproving this?

Best answer:

Answer by MIKE L
The Russians did so many five year plans on farming and production of house hold
products and cars they all failed .

Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!



Tags:Communists, energy, environmentalists, fiveyear, Green, like, Plans

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Site Search